Sie befinden Sich nicht im Netzwerk der Universität Paderborn. Der Zugriff auf elektronische Ressourcen ist gegebenenfalls nur via VPN oder Shibboleth (DFN-AAI) möglich. mehr Informationen...
Was Western Capitalism a Product of an Error in Reasoning? The Weber Thesis and Newcomb's Problem
Ist Teil von
Max Weber studies, 2005-01, Vol.5 (1), p.35-57
Ort / Verlag
Max Weber Studies
Erscheinungsjahr
2005
Link zum Volltext
Quelle
Alma/SFX Local Collection
Beschreibungen/Notizen
This article demonstrates how Weber's ideal typical Calvinist in choosing between the 'worldly ascetic' and the usual opportunistic way of life confronts Newcomb's problem. Weber's presentation of the Calvinist predicament exemplifies a distinct case of Newcomb's problem with an infallible predictor, but with asymmetry in the auspiciousness of agent's choices. Because of this asymmetry, Weber's presentation is free from the charge of incoherence, to which Newcomb's problem with an infallible predictor is exposed. Weber's qualification of the Calvinist's choice as 'non-logical' reveals the causalism of his preanalytic intuitions about rational choice. His view implies that one of the contributing causes in the emergence of Western capitalism was the conflation between diagnostic and causal relevance of actions. Re-consideration of the Calvinist's predicament in the framework of Robert Nozick's decision value theory provides promising framework for the elaboration of Weberian problematics of 'rationalization', of social action and 'disenchantment' of the world, and shows how the rationality of Calvinist's choice can be vindicated.