Details

Autor(en) / Beteiligte

• Guczalski, Krzysztof

Titel

The Density of Symbol Systems – A Critique of Nelson Goodman’s Notion

Ist Teil von

• Philosophia (Ramat Gan), 2022-07, Vol.50 (3), p.1131-1152

Ort / Verlag

Dordrecht: Springer Netherlands

Erscheinungsjahr

2022

Link zum Volltext

Quelle

SpringerNature Journals

Beschreibungen/Notizen

• Nelson Goodman’s theory of symbol systems expounded in his Languages of Art has been frequently criticized on many counts (cf. list of secondary literature in the entry “Goodman’s Aesthetics” of Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy and Sect. 3 below). Yet it exerts a strong influence and is treated as one of the major twentieth-century theories on the subject. While many of Goodman’s controversial theses are criticized, the technical notions he used to formulate them seem to have been treated as neutral tools. One such technical notion is that of the density of symbol systems. This serves to distinguish linguistic symbols from pictorial representations (after Goodman entirely rejected resemblance in that role) and is a crucial part of Goodman’s explanation of what constitutes aesthetic experience (and so indirectly what is art). Thus its significance for Goodman’s theory is fundamental. The aim of this paper is a detailed, logical analysis of this notion. It turns out that Goodman’s definition is highly problematic and cannot be applied to symbol systems in the way Goodman envisaged. To conclude, Goodman’s theory is problematic not just because of its controversial theses but also because of logical problems with the technical notions used at its very core. Hence the controversial claims are not simply contestable, but inaccurately expressed.