Details

Autor(en) / Beteiligte

• Buder-Gröndahl, Tommi

Titel

The ambiguity of BERTology: what do large language models represent?

Ist Teil von

• Synthese (Dordrecht), 2023-12, Vol.203 (1), p.15, Article 15

Ort / Verlag

Dordrecht: Springer Netherlands

Erscheinungsjahr

2023

Link zum Volltext

Quelle

SpringerNature Journals

Beschreibungen/Notizen

• The field of “BERTology” aims to locate linguistic representations in large language models (LLMs). These have commonly been interpreted as representing structural descriptions (SDs) familiar from theoretical linguistics, such as abstract phrase-structures. However, it is unclear how such claims should be interpreted in the first place. This paper identifies six possible readings of “linguistic representation” from philosophical and linguistic literature, concluding that none has a straight-forward application to BERTology. In philosophy, representations are typically analyzed as cognitive vehicles individuated by intentional content. This clashes with a prevalent mentalist interpretation of linguistics, which treats SDs as (narrow) properties of cognitive vehicles themselves. I further distinguish between three readings of both kinds, and discuss challenges each brings for BERTology. In particular, some readings would make it trivially false to assign representations of SDs to LLMs, while others would make it trivially true. I illustrate this with the concrete case study of structural probing: a dominant model-interpretation technique. To improve the present situation, I propose that BERTology should adopt a more “LLM-first” approach instead of relying on pre-existing linguistic theories developed for orthogonal purposes.